The European Parliament’s PEST Committee reached the wrong conclusions and disregarded key evidence, a new report concludes.
Anthea McIntyre MEP, the European Conservatives and Reformists Group co-ordinator on the temporary committee, has produced an alternative report assessing the evidence put before members and suggesting different recommendations.
Launching “The European Union’s Authorisation Procedure for Pesticides: A Science-Based Approach”, she said she wanted to set the record straight and offer balance to the committee’s proposals for the future of pesticides regulation.
Miss McIntyre, MEP for the West Midlands and Conservative spokesman on agriculture, had tabled a raft of amendments to the original PEST report when it went before the parliament, but they were unsuccessful.
PEST chairman Eric Andrieu subsequently launched a personal attack on Miss McIntyre at a press conference.
Miss McIntyre said: “This report is about promoting better regulation, not settling scores.
"Despite hearing from a range of experts and authorities, the report was prepared in a very selective manner, with many of these experts’ contributions being completely disregarded. The report was extremely disappointing and reflected poorly on the work of European Parliament."
And the McIntyre report concludes: "Regrettably...rather than offer a balanced, thoughtful reflection on the legislative framework the (PEST) report purposefully vilifies those involved, from EFSA (the European Food Safety Agency) to national competent authorities, and underplays (their) effectiveness..."
Miss Mcintyre told the launch: "Our current system isn’t perfect and can be improved. The EU can act to improve transparency, something the Commission has already done with its legislative proposal to revise the General Food Law. We should encourage innovation - new farming techniques can reduce the need for pesticides. We should support scientific development - new active substances can make older, more persistent chemistry, obsolete.
"The Commission, EU regulatory agencies, Member State authorities and Greenpeace, who all gave evidence to the PEST Committee, said it was not flaws in the legislation that needed to be addressed, but improvements in its implementation. This report should have struck a balance and reflected the breadth of expert testimony it heard.
"I want the voice of rational, science-based reasoning to be heard and to support farmers who are the ones that will inevitably bear the brunt of further burdensome regulation.
“So this report presents the evidence which was given to the PEST Committee by a variety of experts, which was not properly recognised in the official report, or was simply ignored.”
Anthea McIntyre has written to The Times about police claims that taxpayers are subsidising shooting.
"The West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner is laying it on thick, to say the least, when he claims police forces are subsidising shooting to the tune of £10 million.
"Leaving aside the suspiciously round numbers he quotes, which have the whiff of fag packet about them, his claims dodge the more important issue - the failure of police forces to make processing efficient and fit for the digital age.
"As Mr Jamieson's local MEP and a member of the European Parliament's Biodiversity, Hunting and Countryside Intergroup, I urge him to consider the evidence of gun-users themselves. The British Association for Shooting and Conservation points to long delays in licensing, engrained inefficiency, a chaotic approach to medical checks and failure to embrace new technology.
"Only two out of forty- three forces have introduced online registration systems that were promised the last time fees were raised.
"The anti-shooting lobby reveals its class-based bias in your article with the claim that people who spend £1,000 for "a day's shooting and champagne" can afford more for a gun licence.
"Guns are not a luxury toy for the wealthy but a working tool for people involved in land management, practical conservation and control of vermin that raid food stores and spread disease.
"The licensing process is an important safeguard made on society's behalf. It needs to be brought up to date."
Anthea McIntyre joined fellow Conservative MEPs today in opposing moves to ban an important chemical used for protecting components for the aerospace industry.
The Conservative employment spokesman in the European Parliament condemned a bid by Green MEPs and members of the parliament's Environment Committee to overturn the EU Commission's safety-approval for chromium trioxide, which is widely used to coat engine parts and other components to make them more robust and longer-lasting.
She spoke out after Dutch Green MEP Bas Eickhout tabled a motion opposing the Commission’s implementing measure approving certain uses of chromium trioxide, on the basis that the Commission was exceeding its powers.
Although CrO3 is acknowledged as a potential carcinogen, its use as a coating has long been allowed subject to strict procedures and exposure limits.
Miss McIntyre, MEP for the West Midlands, said: "This is a ruse by ultra-zealous Leftist and Green extremists who really want to close down the chemicals industry and take down the continent's economy with it.
"Their claim that the Commission has exceeded its powers is utterly spurious must be roundly rejected.
"Our expert engineers need this treatment. It is used within well-recognised safety limits to make high tech parts more resistant to wear and rust. Longer-lasting components mean less demand on the earth's resources - so anyone who really cares about the environment should be supporting the process, not trying to stop it.
"In my own region, Birmingham's Indestructible Paint Company produces high-tech coatings for Rolls Royce engines and other aerospace companies and uses CrO3 as a vital part of the process.
"Nationally, surface engineering contributes £14.8Bn to the UK economy, which in turn creates ten times that value in manufactured products and supports 30,000 UK jobs.
"We must defy the scaremongers and make sure this safe usage is allowed to continue."
In Strasbourg today MEPs voted narrowly in favour of the Eickhout objection.
It is now up to the Commission to decide whether to heed the vote.
Anthea McIntyre, Conservative employment spokesman in the European Parliament, has welcomed today’s UK jobs figures showing continued increases in wages and people in work.
The West Midlands MEP said: “Britain continues to set the standard for the rest of Europe in the creation of quality jobs.
“More people are in work than ever before and their wages are rising at their fastest for 10 years.
“This is what happens when you create the right climate for growth and enterprise and then let businesses do what comes naturally.”
The anti hate-crime body West Midlands Together has condemned the New Zealand Mosque attacks and called for a united stance against hatred and evil.
The cross-party organisation's co-chair Anthea McIntyre, Conservative MEP for the West Midlands, said: "Events in New Zealand have demonstrated the sickening depths some fanatics will stoop to when they are driven by blind hatred and irrational fear.
"We at West Midlands Together stand with the good people of New Zealand in vowing that this poison must not take hold, this evil must not win."
Page 8 of 75